Wednesday, November 18, 2026

What Are Friends For?

 

This morning I finished "Once Upon A Glitched Call", the new storyline chapter for Neverness To Everness that arrived with Version 1.5, a week or so back. It took me almost exactly three hours, about two hours and fifty-five minutes of which I spent sitting back and watching. It was some of the best "gaming" I've done this year.

From this point on there will be many spoilers, so if there's any chance you might want to experience it for yourself, something I'd recommend most highly, I'd suggest coming back later, when you've done just that. I'll hum to myself a moment while you slip away...

Okay. And now, for the folks who aren't really interested in all the nitpicking detail of a game they're never going to play but just want the score, here's the tl:dr. 

  • Story: Excellent  - 10/10
  • Visuals: Excellent - 10/10
  • Voice Acting: Excellent - 10/10
  • Music: Excellent - 10/10

There! That's saved you all a few minutes. See you next time.

For the handful of people still reading, those who play the game and/or like to hear about good storytelling, let's get down to detail.

It has, as you'll have noticed, taken me quite a while to get around to taking a look at this new chapter. In part that's because the storyline in NTE is episodic at best, so it's not like I was desperate to know what was going to happen next. 

 

Mostly, though, it was because I wasn't all that excited by the prospect of sitting through what I was pretty certain would be an entire anime movie, starring two characters I'd never heard of as they plowed through some iffy plotline involving mysterious phone-calls. I'd seen the character PV that came out ahead of the update and it didn't grab my interest as much as previous promos for the game. It didn't really make a lot of sense at all. 

I've just watched that PV again and it makes far more sense, now I've played through the actual story. It's really quite powerful in context. As a promo, though, it's just confusing. Combined with a weak Version 1.5 PV, I wasn't feeling the hype at all. It seemed very unlikely whatever was coming would be able to match the really top quality witch trial episode we got last time.

About that...

Once Upon A Glitched Call isn't just one of the best gaming experiences I've had this year. It's some of the best storytelling I've seen in any medium. The writing is easily up there with the scripts for TV shows or movies in similar genres that I've seen. I guess that's less surprising when you realize it pretty much is a TV show or a movie.

It's three hours long for a start and that really is three full hours of dialog and animation. There are precisely three fight sequences, one of which is completely trivial and the other two of which are very easy. Add them all together and remove the cut scenes at the end of the big fights, where you just watch your character doing it all so much better than you ever could, and the whole lot probably comes to less than five minutes.

There's not even much time spent traveling or doing puzzles and when either of those things is happening, characters are usually talking all the way through. There really is very little of the three hours when someone isn't speaking. 

 

I'm pretty good at paying attention to dialog in long scenes. I tend to commit quite fully to immersing myself in the story when I watch a movie or watch a TV show. I don't like to be interrupted and I don't interrupt myself. I only start when I know I have a clear window to see it through to the end. Even so, my mind does sometimes wander, if there's all talk and no action.

My mind did not wander at all during the whole three hours of this one. I found the storyline compelling right from the start. I did take it in two bites, a two-hour session on the laptop in bed last night and an hour at the desktop this morning, but I only broke it up because I (Wrongly.) believed we were going into a big action sequence after a couple of hours and I didn't want to do fighting on the laptop. Otherwise, I could very easily have gone the whole three hours in one sitting, which is something I rarely manage with a movie.

I have, finally, had to accept that video games can tell stories in a way that can't be replicated in any other medium. I did not feel that way until I played Wuthering Waves and now I feel Neverness to Everness has taken it to another level. 

It's not because the storytelling is better there - WW, back when I was playing it, was probably even better-written. It's more the way both the visuals and the player's input in NTE are put to use so effectively, always in service to the story. 

When I say it's three hours of watching, that's not strictly true. There are countless moments when the player is invited to examine the scene even while other things are happening all around. It creates a dense palimpsest of information that's intentionally not just difficult but impossible to take in. The main characters hold conversations as the player examines items that bring up text to be read, all while memories of the past are play out in sound and vision in the background. 

 

I gave up trying to catch every last word and just let the story build around me. I found it highly immersive, although I can imagine others finding it annoying or frustrating. You are going to miss things. You just have to let them go.

Equally, the long sequence where you have to walk slowly across the screen with computer files drifting behind you until you tow them to the correct hardware so they'll reveal their contents could be received as either infuriating or charming, according to your taste. I loved it. I loved pretty much everything about the whole story, in fact, not just the way it was told, which was exceptional, but the text and subtext of the story itself. 

I'd summarize the plot but to reduce it to a linear narrative would do it no justice at all. It's genuinely complex and exquisitely nuanced. I routinely find myself astonished, these days, by just what seems to be considered appropriate subject matter in the games I'm playing. Once Upon A Glitched Call is at one and the same time a tense thriller and a metaphysical treatise on the nature of memory, humanity and especially friendship. 

I'm still not wholly used to having to think this hard, let alone this deeply, when I sit down to play a game. I don't have to put in this much mental effort for most of the novels I read. It's hardly surprising I've been having a blast letting off some steam in Soulframe lately. They're both games but it's the difference between entering a chess tournament and having a kick-around down the park. A bit of mindless violence with no real context is a freshener, sometimes.

At the considerable risk of devaluing the aforementioned complexity and nuance, I will at least try to give some impression of what goes on. It all begins when the Appraiser takes a commission from Nitsa of ETD-6. 

 

ETD-6 is one of the more secretive divisions of the Bureau. It deals primarily with esper crime but also with some of the more serious anomalies. A chance meeting with Edgar, in which he talks about an urban legend involving an invalid phone number that crops up in dreams, leads Zero to Nitsa, who's worried about the two officers of that division, Lieutenant Elyms and Captain Exe, (Aka X, because everyone in this story has to have at least two names..) who've both been missing for a while.

Zero, aka The Appraiser (aka Flora in my game.) signs on to find Elyms, about whom Nitsa is concerned, and ends up in a vast anomalous realm. From there, a long narrative plays out, involving a meme anomaly known as the Imaginary Old Friend, the two ETD-6 officers and an esper known only as Y, who was supposedly trapped inside a computer, where they died several years ago.

As the narrative winds on, Zero realizes two terrible facts (At least two. Quite possibly more than two. But two will do for now.) First, Elyms is the Imaginary Old Friend and second, Exe is hell-bent on nullifying her. 

It transpires that the Director of the Bureau knows Elyms is an anomaly, not a human, and she's fine with that. (She's also fine with Exe being a total psychopath. It must be fun working for her...) Exe knows, too, and he very much is not fine with it. He's already killed Elyms numerous times but, being a meme anomaly, she doesn't stay dead. He's working on that.

The rest of ETD-6 are oblivious to any of this so now Zero knows more about the team than half the team does, leaving her in possession of classified information, way above her security clearance. She's also taken a commission to find Elyms and bring her back safely only to find her client's boss is trying to kill the person she's supposed to be rescuing. 

 

If, that is, Elyms is a person. That's something neither Flora nor Elyms herself knows for sure. We're all here to find that out, together.

There is much discussion of the nature of humanity, of individuality, of the intrinsic and extrinsic value of truth, memory and friendship and a whole lot more metaphysics, philosophy and psychology besides. It's exactly the kind of thing that too often weighs down popular media that tries to punch above its intellectual weight. Mostly I find it tedious. Sometimes it can be embarrassing.

Except here it all just works. The dialog is clear, lucid, easy to follow and never awkward. The voice actors give every line its best reading. It's just a joy to read along and listen to them act. Honestly, this sort of thing really should not work in a video game. But it does.

There's a lot more to it than that (A lot more...) but I'm not going to be doing it any favors by retailing it all here, second-hand. I'll just pick out a few things that particularly struck me as either highlights or as even more unusual than the rest.

For example, the way the Appraiser quite quickly starts to think of Exe as a murderer. Specifically that: A Murderer. It's not a word that crops up often in games of this kind. Killer, sure. Villain, always. Murderer, though? Not so much.

And she means it quite specifically. Elyms uses it,too. Even Exe uses it about himself. The writers are determined not to gloss over what's happening with euphemism. 

Murder is what this all about. The whole thing even takes place on Ghroth Island, Hethrerau's version of Alcatraz. Exe specifically goes there so that, when he's tried for murder, they won't have far too take him. He's such a considerate psychopath...

 

He is a psychopath, too. Or maybe a sociopath. He's an obsessive monomaniac, anyway, able to see other viewpoints than his own but still wholly indifferent to them. He is overtly willing to kill the close friends of three hundred thousand people just to make sure the memory of his own, dead, friend is not, as he sees it, violated. That, to him, is an entirely reasonable course of action.

And he makes a good case for it. He's wrong. So wrong. But he's not confused or mistaken or misled or any get-out that might let Zero or anyone else bring him around at the end. She tries but it can't be done. He's psychotic. He is not amenable to reason. He understands the logic. He agrees with it, objectively. It just doesn't apply to him.

So he kills Elyms, again and for good this time. Only not. Because he may be good at what he does (Where have I heard that before?) but he's not that good, after all.  

Then there's his method. Guess how he plans to murder Elyms so she won't come back this time? There's a big, big clue at the top of the post. He shoots himself in the head. That's him up there, doing it. He's engineered it so the last remaining failsafe backup from which Elyms could reboot herself is in his head. So he shoots himself.

That was the moment that surprised me the most. He had the gun to his head and I thought "He won't do it." Then I thought "If he does it, we won't see him do it." But he did. And we did.

Murder and suicide in the same story. They're really pushing those boundaries, aren't they, these writers? Good for them. It's entirely justified by the context. Maybe having Exe blow his brains out every time as the animation for his Ultimate might be a bit more morally problematic, but that's not a problem for the writers...

 

On a very much lighter note, I loved Elyms' computer game, a gorgeously pixelated excursion into a delightful, wholesome and visually charming vision of Hethereau, where all the action revolves around making friends with strangers. That turned out to be the "action" I logged out of the laptop to avoid.  

The only real action, two boss fights, one where you play as Exe as you attempt to murder Elyms and the other where the Appraiser tries to beat some sense into Exe, while giving Elyms time to get herself back together, are both extremely easy. It's just as well. There's no time to learn Exe's power set anyway, so it's lucky button mashing works.

Other than that, plus a couple of derisory fights with oddities in a corridor, there's no combat at all. Just a very, very great deal of talking. And I loved every word. Or, to quote Lacrimosa, who plays absolutely no part in the story at all, I love, love, loved it! 

As a result of playing through the whole story, I'm now quite keen on adding Elyms to my team. She'd be the only anomaly among them for a start, plus I really like her. 

Exe, on the other hand, I wouldn't take if he came free with a transfer bonus of 10,000,000 Fons. He calls Elyms a "monster" all through the story but we all know who the real monster is, don't we?

I could go on and on, not just because I enjoyed the whole thing so much but because there really is one whole hell of a lot to talk about. But I'm already past my notional 2k words soft limit for the post, so I'd better stop.

I suspect my reaction to this story will not be typical. It's likely too wordy and abstruse for some but it played very closely to several longstanding, personal interests of mine - imaginary friends, the nature of consciousness and self-awareness, the composition and integrity of memory - and it handled all of them much better than I'm used to seeing them handled. 

Commercial, it may not be, action-packed it most certainly isn't, but I'll take one of these every six weeks for as long as they keep them coming. 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Chairs Missing

I just left a comment at Contains Moderate Peril, rambling on about how I wasn't going to be spending a lot of money on a gaming PC and agreeing with Roger that managing the storage I already have would make better sense than just buying more all the time. All of which is very much a "Do what I say, not what I do" scenario, of course, because if there's one thing I do enjoy spending money, on it's gadgets. Not to mention that the possibility of me ever getting sufficiently organized (Or ruthless enough.) to put my overflowing disk drives in order, let alone keep them that way, is notional at best.

And things just go wrong sometimes or break. Then you have to replace them. Or repair them. I posted a fair bit, earlier in the year, about things going wrong with my PC, for example. 

When I needed to replace my failing decade-old PC last year, I had the smart idea, or so I thought at the time, of getting the cheapest replacement that would still be capable of running the kind of games I like to play, few of which are particularly taxing on hardware. I used Baldur's Gate 3 as a benchmark and bought the best-looking option, at the lowest cost, that was able to run it. I paid about £350, took the two-year old graphics card out of my old machine, slapped it in the new one, and for six months that set-up worked perfectly.

After six months, though, it started to develop problems, until eventually it was barely functional. It looked like I'd have to return it under warranty and think about buying a Real Gaming PC for about four or five times the cost. I prevaricated, mostly because it was a Return-to-Base warranty and I'd have had to package the machine up and send it back and I just could not be bothered. Which turned out to be just as well.

Having heard how AIs had helped other people to fix technical issues such as I was having, I asked ChatGPT for help. Between us we eventually got my PC back in fully working order. It's been fine since then, mostly. It still occasionally crashes on exit after playing a game although it is only very occasionally. I'm pretty much certain that's due to the way the onboard graphics, which are quite powerful by the standards of such things, use paging files as a substitute for there not being any actual vRAM. Having an actual GPU in the mix probably just complicates things.

So long as it doesn't escalate into the kind of problem it was before, the occasional crash when I log out of a game is a compromise I'm happy to accept for saving myself more than a thousand pounds by not buying an actual gaming PC, an expense I've already avoided twice.

Back in the summer, I spent quite a few hours pricing and comparing real gaming PCs. I went on the websites of the two best-known "Build your own PC" suppliers in the UK and fiddled around with things, swapping all kinds of components in and out, trying to get the best machine for the best price. I had several builds saved that would have run me somewhere around £1500, four or five times the cost of the machine I'm using now, and I was very close to making a final choice, when I found myself wondering just exactly what I'd do with such a machine, if I had one.

I could run games in a higher resolution, I guess, but I can't say I've felt any desire to do that since I first got an HD monitor. 1080p seems fine to me. I also don't particularly want a bigger screen than the 23" model I'm looking at right now. 

When that finally dies, I might go for something a couple of inches bigger but nothing much more than that, I think. I sit about 25" away from the screen (I just measured it.) and it feels like a larger monitor would be too much at that distance.

I very definitely don't want a second monitor. I don't even like to have multiple windows open on the same one unless it's absolutely necessary. I like to work (Or game.) with one full screen image in front of me. I'll alt-tab when I need to and have another the same. Then, when I'm done, I'll alt-tab back. That feels natural, like turning the pages of a book. Anything else feels awkward.

Sidebar - Remember when Picture-in-Picture first came in? I had a PiP television in the '90s and it seemed like magic. You could be watching a soap opera and have a sports game in a little image in the corner so you could follow the score. Not that I did that, not being much of a sports fan, but I could see the value in it. I never really found a use for it and then it seemed to go out of fashion for a long time. I forgot all about it. 

And now suddenly it's back! I keep getting little pop-out windows spawning when I watch YouTube videos and Firefox just proudly announced a PiP feature in a recent update. I use it a little but it still feels like a gimmick. Was there a demand for it, I wonder, or do these companies just add stuff for the hell of it?

All of that might turn out to be completely wrong if I put it to the test. I might find I absolutely loved having two 32" 4K monitors. It would be a pretty expensive experiment to find out, though, and I'd have to start from a position of being dissatisfied with what I have. Which I'm not.

As for the power and capabilities of the PC itself, once again it comes down to what I'd want to do with it. I'm amenable to the idea that having more power than you need allows you to run everything more smoothly but the evidence is that I already have more power than I need. I believe there's an inherent problem with the specific design of the setup I'm using but I don't think that relates to it being underpowered. 

I just should probably have picked a machine with a separate GPU, not one that sold itself on the pretty good graphic capabilities of the CPU itself. Then again, I can play a lot of the games I like to play on those inbuilt graphics, so I have redundancy should the GPU fail (And vice versa, I guess...), which is always nice.

Roger was actually posting about the cost of storage and SSDs rather than the price of PCs as a whole. There he makes a very good point, which is that, for years, the obvious solution to running out of hard drive space has been Buy More Storage. SSDs started out very expensive and became very cheap. HDDs were cheaper still. Until the rising tide of demand from AI data centers lifted all prices, it really didn't make much sense to keep uninstalling games you might want to play again a few months later. Just get another, bigger drive.

That's why I have four drives in this PC - three SSDs and a mechanical HDD. Plus several more I can put into enclosures and hook up through the USB slots. Which sounds fine until I actually want to find something. 

Before I had to reinstall Windows on my new M3 drive, almost the whole of my desktop was covered with icons because that was just about the only way I could rely on being able to locate the games or apps I needed. The reinstall cleared the desktop completely and since then I've been trying to keep it that way. I currently have just two columns of icons and the start of a third, leaving 95% of the screen clear for me to look at pictures of Hethereau. Aesthetically, it's a huge improvement but god forbid I want to play any games that aren't up there. 

Of course, since almost all the games I play nowadays are either on Steam or GeForce Now, why would I need to look for them on the desktop or in the Start Menu or on the drives? Both platforms do an infinitely better job of keeping everything neat and tidy than I ever would. 

That's why I get increasingly irritated by any game that isn't on one or the other. The fact that I'm playing so much Soulframe, when it has to be opened via a standalone launcher from a desktop icon, says a lot about how keen I've been to play it. I am, however, only a snap of the fingers away from deciding against trying new any new game if it isn't on either Steam or GFN.

Looking ahead, I find it increasingly unlikely I'd want to invest in a "real" gaming PC again. If a £350 machine can play most titles I'm interested in, natively, and if it's more than likely that any really essential AAA title will be on GFN, where's my incentive to pay more?

With storage cost spiraling upwards and the demands of cutting-edge graphics driving the price of true gaming PCs well into the thousands (Dollars or pounds.) I have to wonder how long AAA gaming is going to be able to retain its allure as mass-market entertainment. There's been a lot of pushback against the idea that the next generation of games consoles might top a thousand dollars for the basic model but that's going to look cheap next to the price of even a mid-range gaming PC.

I'm writing about this today mostly because of Roger's post but I was going to be giving at least a couple of paragraphs over to the topic of the cost of keeping a gaming and PC hobby going, whatever else I wrote. That's because of something that happened this morning, when I sat down at my computer desk.

It wasn't anything to do with the PC. That's working just fine (Fingers crossed, touch wood.) It was something a little less... technological. I sat down in my chair and it lurched downwards and to the left, almost throwing me into the wall.

Yep. My chair broke. I can't really complain. By my estimate it must be getting on for thirty years old. It used to be my step-father's and he died in 2003. I think he'd probably had it for a good five years before then. 

I am currently sitting in Mrs Bhapgpuss's old computer chair, which is hard and wobbly and covered with grey velveteen. It could more properly be called Beryl's Chair because, when it got to be too rickety and Mrs Bhagpuss got herself a new one, I put it at the back of my room so Beryl could sit in it when she comes to visit. 

The dog now has an upgrade. My chair may be unfit for computer duties now something terminal has happened to the support strut but it's more than up to the job of making Beryl comfortable. It does take up a lot of space but I'll bet it's going to stay because she's going to love it. She's always enjoyed a go in it, whenever I haven't been using it.

I spent a very dull hour this morning, looking at replacements on Amazon. Building imaginary gaming PCs back in the summer was quite good fun but looking at dozens of almost identical swivel chairs does not have the same geeky appeal. 

I've ruled out anything that calls itself a "gaming chair" on the grounds of taste and decorum. Boy, are those things ugly. I'd like something as close the chair I've been sitting in for the last two decades as possible but so far I haven't been able to find an exact match. 

In the time it's taken to write the first draft of this post, though, the stand-in chair has made my backside go numb, so I'm going to have to make a decision soon. At least data center demand doesn't seem to have driven up the price of chairs. 

I don't suppose AIs need to sit down.

 

Notes on AI used in this post

That first picture of a chair? The wonky one? That looks like it's in a clean, white, empty room with some sort of gray parquet-effect vinyl flooring? Well, it's not.

I used SnapEdit to remove all the parts of the photo that weren't the chair, by which I mean everything in my actual room; the carpet, part of a bookcase, a half-open door, a wall heater... 

It wasn't that I wanted to decontextualize it or hide the evidence of an extremely untidy lifestyle, although that did turn out to be the unintended outcome. It was just that there was so much clutter in the background you could barely make the chair out at all. I had no idea what SnapEdit's AI would be able to do because I've never tried to remove the entire background from a photo before but I just painted over everything that wasn't the chair and this is what I got. 

And it's pretty good, I think. The point isn't whether the background looks realistic or convincing. (It doesn't.) It's whether it brings the subject into focus so it can be seen clearly and it does. I do wonder, though, to what extent this is really "AI" at all. Isn't this just what people have been doing in PhotoShop for decades? I could probably have done it myself in Paint.Net, if I had the patience. Only, this took me about thirty seconds instead of half an hour.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Playing And Not Playing

I don't have one whole hell of a lot to talk about today so I thought I'd just do one of those posts about what I'm playing. Everyone does them, although I'm not entirely clear on what the point is supposed to be. Although not everything has to have a point, does it? That's reductionist thinking. Let's not encourage it.

I wonder, though... Are they meant to act as some kind of historical record, where you go back a year or two later to remind yourself of what you were doing? Sometimes, when I do that, it feels like reading about someone else's life. I can't always remember playing the games at all, let alone what I did in them. It usually comes back to me as I'm reading but not always.

I guess reading stories about what it's like to be playing a particular game serves something of the same purpose as a more formal review. It could give you a feel for a game you might be thinking of trying or put the idea of playing one you hadn't really thought about into your head. I feel that watching a Let's Play video or a live stream would do a better job of that, although I suppose it would depend on the streamer. There's been a bit of an issue with that sort of thing in some games of late, or so I've heard. 

Then there's the possibility that someone could be reading the posts purely for the pleasure of the prose. Good writing - or just writing that's to your taste - can be a pleasure, regardless of the topic. Some bloggers- Wilhelm or Tipa or Shintar  for example - can turn just about any gaming session into a entertaining story.

None of which really explains why I'm happy to read Nogamara at Battle Stance, posting a couple of sentences about how the week's raiding went in World of Warcraft. It really shouldn't be interesting to me at all, let alone amusing, and yet somehow it always is. 

I'm not playing WoW at the moment and if I was, I wouldn't be raiding. I have zero interest in the raiding game, not in Azeroth or anywhere else. Less than zero, in fact. I don't recognize any of the names of the mobs, I have no knowledge of the lore (Which Nogamara never mentions anyway.) and the posts make absolutely no attempt to contextualize or even describe any thing about the experience at all, other than how many wipes there were and if someone's cat threw up.

And yet I lap them up like they were reports for some sport I actually followed. Why? I have no idea. I mean, they don't take long to read, so there's that.

Anyway, on the basis that I get something out of those, I feel like it might not be wholly self-indulgent to post the odd note about what I've been up to. Of course anything I post is probably going to take a lot longer to read than Nogamara...

I'll start with the game I should be playing: EverQuest II. There are several reasons why it ought to be top of my login list right now, starting with the pragmatic fact that it's the only one I'm paying for. My annual All Access sub came due in October and I let it auto-renew. I also pre-ordered the upcoming expansion. 

Neither of these choices makes any financial sense. I've barely touched the game for months. I haven't played it to any great extent all year. I think there may be some small saving in renewing my annual sub rather letting it lapse and re-subbing monthly, if and when I start playing again, but even if there is, the savings from just a couple of months of not paying anything would probably be enough to make up for any discount I'd lose by not hanging on to the 12 month discount.

As for the expansion, there's no benefit whatsoever for me in pre-ordering it. There are no useful pre-order perks and I have no interest in joining the beta. I might as well wait and buy it when I'm ready to play.

But I don't care. I've had a subscription of some kind to some version of EverQuest since 1999, even though there have been whole years when I wasn't playing any Daybreak games at all. It's a responsibility I don't feel ready to shirk quite yet. I'd hate to think of them going out of business just because I'd let my subscription lapse.

Still, I might have to revisit that blind (And idiotic.) loyalty if I end up barely playing this expansion either. I only did the bare minimum in the last one. 

Honestly, if they do lose me as a paying customer, it'll be because of the decision they made to go back to making it so slow and tedious to level multiple characters to the cap. Back when I could get the last five or ten levels done in a few sessions, I enjoyed going back every month or so for maybe a week so I could get one more of the crew leveled up. Now I can't face doing it more than once. I see the expansion storyline through to the end and I'm about finished for the year.

The second reason I should have been playing EQII this week, apart from getting something for the money I'm paying, is directly related to that glacial leveling speed. Every year, Daybreak makes a big effort to raise money for Extra Life and they always do well. They tie the donations to various in-game rewards, one of which is always a huge XP buff. This year they raised $100k and gave everyone a week-long 275% XP bonus.

My first thought was to log in and take advantage of it on my Berserker but then I remembered that, last time something like this happened, I tried that, it was very disappointing. The only way to get meaningful XP in the higher levels is to do quests, particularly main storyline quests, and the XP comes at the end of stages which often take a whole session or more to finish. 

It's really dispiriting, knowing you supposedly have a huge XP buff but not seeing any actual XP coming in. If I was playing normally, a session or two most days, then the buff would be very helpful but, unlike in the old days, when killing mobs, especially in dungeons, gave gobs of xp per kill, you can't just log in when there's bonus xp and expect to get a few levels done in a session or two.

 

And the third reason, as if I needed another, is that they've brought back one of the most enjoyable special events the game ever had - Dragon Attack.  It was created for the 15th Anniversary and has never been repeated until now. At the time, I summed it up as "So much better than I thought it was going to be." and for once I can remember it quite well. I'd love to do it again. In theory. In practice, it seems, not so much.

So, I haven't even logged in to EQII, in spite having all those good reasons, which means so far this has been a post about the games I'm not playing. Let's run with that for another paragraph..

Other games I tell myself I want to play, but which I haven't in any practical sense played, include, but aren't limited to, Dragon Nest Classic, Valheim, Once Human, Wuthering Waves, New World and Nighthawks. I have yet even to log in to that last one, despite having bought it the day it came out, and even watching and reviewing Edgerunners Season 2 didn't get me back to WW to see what they'd done there with the collab.

The games I have been playing are Soulframe, Neverness to Everness and Nivalis Nights, with Soulframe very much taking the lead. Since I downloaded it out of curiosity it's become, if not a minor obsession, then still very much the first game I think about playing every day. 

A great deal of that is novelty but even there, as must be evident by the number of games I write about once or twice and then never again, novelty wears off fast. Soulframe is past being new to me, to the extent that I can already see how grindy and repetitive it's likely to get. Probably sooner rather than later, at that, and yet I look forward to playing it rather more keenly than I've been used to looking to forward to playing any game since Baldur's Gate 3, back at the beginning of the year.

I put most of my enthusiasm down to a couple of things: the combat is really good fun and there's a very direct correlation between playing the game and seeing things improve. I haven't played a game where I enjoyed fighting for the sake of fighting since BG3. It makes a welcome change from games where everything is talk talk talk. I never remember how much I enjoy a good fighting game until I run into one by accident.

 

As for the progression, I'm still at the stage where completing long quests adds new NPCs to my base. I got the Witch, Verminia, a few days ago and yesterday I got the Blacksmith, Tuvulkane. That means I can now use cosmetics, change my appearance and craft potions and armor.  Or, rather, have the NPCs craft it for me.

Next up, I think, is killing a three-headed bear. I already killed him once, after about a dozen failed attempts, but his body went under the world so my flying fairy-rat couldn't swoop down his throat to pluck the seed we wanted out of his stomach. 

I had to fight the bear down a hole you can't climb out of. I'm guessing if you recover the seed some magic portal opens but since that didn't happen, I had to log out and now I'm outside, about half a mile away, looking not just at redoing the fight but clearing my the way through the miles of tunnels to get to it as well.

And I'm kinda looking forward to it, which is weird. I usually hate having to redo fights but although this one is intense and very nearly too hard for me, each attempt only takes about thirty seconds, which makes al the difference. If this was Guild Wars 2, every failure would mean another attritional battle lasting half an hour or more but I could probably attempt to beat the bear at least thirty times in the same time it would take me to do on GW2 boss fight. I'm pretty much bound to get him, just by luck, before then. 

I'm also plugging away at the tasks required to cleanse the land of corruption, the reward for which will be some nice scenery to look at. Not that I know exactly what those tasks are. The game remains stubbornly unwilling to explain itself. I just do everything that comes up and hope it'll be enough in the end.

 

That's Soulframe. Neverness To Everness is mostly on minimum upkeep right now as I log in every day for half an hour or so to do whatever needs doing, then log out again. The regular dailies only take ten or fifteen minutes but today my City Stamina had refreshed so I spent half an hour serving customers in my cafe, for which I was paid about half a million Fons. Nice work if you can get it.

I should be getting on with the new storyline but so far I haven't felt like listening to all that talking. I might do it late at night, in the time slot I usually reserve for watching TV, because that's pretty close to how it feels. I admit to feeling slightly demotivated that neither of the Banner characters this time around feels like they're of much interest. 

I like rolling for characters in gacha games and I have enough dice saved up to give it a good old go but it seems like a waste to use them trying to get characters I don't particularly want. I don't really want Shinku on the returning Banner either, although I do quite like her. Maybe after I've seen the new ones in action and gotten to know them better I might feel a bit more motivated. That's certainly what happened with both Blackbird and Linko. Otherwise, it's going to be a long six weeks without rolling for anything.

 

As for Nivalis Nights, I was storming through, playing two or three hours a day and really enjoying it, until Soulframe came along and pushed everything else to the back of the line. The story is building nicely. It's very interesting and the fractured, disconnected way its told is even better. 

More surprisingly, perhaps, I have been enjoying the cafe side of things, too. Just before I got distracted, I was seriously considering buying a second business and seeing if I could make some progress up the owners' ladder. I'm thinking of buying a second cafe in NTE as well so maybe there's something in this cafe management thing after all. 

Well, sure, there is. It's called money. I make most of my Fons from my Moomin Street Cafe Origen franchise and in NN, I'm making a small but steady profit from the noodle bar. I'm starting to think I understand enough about the mechanics now to improve on that significantly.

I'll have to see if I can get back to Nivalis soon or else I'll have forgotten most of the plot. The one big advantage both NTE and NN have over Soulframe is that they're on Geforce Now, which Soulframe isn't and probably never will be. That means I can play them on the laptop in bed. I'm almost at the point where I need to take another break from making songs on Suno, so a slot may be opening up there, soon. 

If it does, no doubt I'll be back here posting about what I've been playing soon enough. And if not, then it'll be about what I've not been playing.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Communication Breakdown

Two weeks brings twenty-eight tunes. That's going to need some culling. At a rough guess, three-quarters of them new names. Well, new to this blog. Does novelty get preference over familiarity? Maybe. Not over quality. 

Oh, hell. Let's just start and see what happens.

 Carottes - 1tbsp, miki

Okay, that was random. But so good! I love French vocals I can't understand. I can, technically, speak and understand French. I did it right into my first year at university, although by then I only had to read it, not speak it. But my first year at university was more than forty-five years ago. These things don't stay with your forever.

Not that I'd ever have been able to understand a song sung in French unless it was A La Bande A Tout Faire that we used to have sing in class when I was about fifteen. No, wait, I think we just had to listen to it at the start of every new chapter of the  audio tape that got played to us when I was doing O-Level French. Except, when I google it, there doesn't seem to be any record of it ever having existed. There's a series of short films called Toute La Bande but that's not it.

I just wasted half an hour trying to find whatever it was that I used to listen to in double French back in the 70s. Que dalle! That's French for not a sausage. Not a sausage in French is pas une saucisse, apparently, but that isn't anything any French person would say, unless, presumably, they were looking at something other than a sausage and wanted to make that quite clear. 

I could sing that song, though. Well, the title, which I used to sing in my head when it was playing in class and which I've sung many, many times since. Looking it up, though, it seems the phrase I have always remembered is meaningless gibberish. It might be a mishearing of "La bonne a tout faire", which is a maid of all work aka a housemaid but what I remember is a story about a group of teenagers who did good deeds or odd jobs, a bit like the Scouts.

Oh, well. Lost to time, if it ever existed. Certainly made for a bizarre start to this post, though. 

Stupid Boy - 1000 Rabbits

If you could resist following a song called Carottes with one by a band called 1000 Rabbits, you have more willpower than I do. Unfortunately. It's horrible programming. Those two songs shouldn't even be on the same radio show, let alone next to each other on the schedule. This train has gone careening catastrophically off the rails before it's even gotten rolling. Let me see if I can do anything to haul it back...

Stop Calling Me Out - Grocery Bag

Alright! Some nice, straight-up rock and roll (Albeit with a vaguely reggaefied bridge...) That should settle things down. Could have been made pretty much any time from about 1972 to... well, now. I like the effort they've put in to get a band "look" with all the red and black right down to the guitars. Didn't the Strokes do that? Don't ask me. I know nothing about the Strokes. They came up in my wilderness years.

As for the name, Grocery Bag is one of those names that genuinely is so bad it's good. When I saw it, literally thought "That's such a terrible name! I have to find out what a band who'd call themselves something like that would sound like." And they sound alright. 

 i spend my time crying - twisted teens

If you want a rock band here in 2026, though, I don't know that you can do a lot better than Twisted Teens. Oh, look, I capitalized them in the text but not in the caption! That's because they have it both ways on their own channel, so I guess It's optional.  One of my favorite videos this year, too. It's a three-minute movie.

Numb - Esther Rose, Angela Autumn

This one's more like a home video but it works. No need for a credits sequence. It was just them and I bet they filmed it on one of their phones. 

 Look at Miss Ohio - Carriers

I guess we're into the Americana section of the show now. This is a cover of a song by Gillian Welch & David Rawlings, a duo I cannot in good conscience pretend I'd ever heard of before I came across this, which Carriers rush-recorded in celebration of the election of Democratic governor-elect for Ohio, Amy Acton. The original is quite a lot more twangy. I prefer the cover.

 Black Boys On Mopeds - Sinead O'Connor

I was about to say that the opposite is true of this one, which I only heard for the first time a week or two ago, when a cover of it came up on either Pitchfork or Stereogum, only now I can't find any such cover. I thought it might have been on TripleJ but no joy there, either. I think actually what happened is there was a cover of something else and it got compared to this but the knowledge is lost, now. It's like the Great Library of Alexandria in my mind; a heap of smouldering rubble.

I know I found it by following a link from something I was reading, anyway, but I guess the provenance doesn't matter. The important thing is that I found it because it's stunning. But then, what did Sinead O'Connor ever write or record that wasn't?  

It is odd that I've never heard it  - or even heard of it - before. Not only is there Sinead's wonderful original but it's been very widely covered by the likes of Pheobe Bridgers, Sharon Van Etten and Fontaines DC. The Fontaines make it sound a lot more Irish than the original, although not nearly as Irish as the excellent version by Madra Salach. Sinead's version sounds almost Americana to me, which is why I slotted it in after Look At Miss Ohio.

 Have I got any more like that?

Summer In Siam - Tom Waits (Pogues cover)

Kinda! Only in reverse.

Is Tom Waits in some kind of private competition with Bob Dylan, where they challenge each other to make everything they sing as hard to understand as possible? I mean, Shane McGowan wasn't exactly the model of clarity but he had the excuse of being drunk most of the time. I saw the Pogues twice and the second time, Shane spent most of the set slumped on the drum riser with his back to the crowd - and he still sounded clearer than this.

 hey boyyy - Slayyyter

Yeah, that's not exactly the trailer park,now, is it? I guess we're not in Americana anymore.

 High Forever - Petite Meller

As I said in my review of Edgerunners Season 2, Petite Meller was tapped to write a song specifically for the closing credits and another that's probably the key song in the body of the show, making her the Rosa Walton of the season. I've always loved what Petite does but that's a high bar. I included the video with scenes from the show in the other post but here's her own original because who doesn't want more Petite Meller to watch?

 Postinternetfame - Quiet Light

I only heard this for the first time yesterday and I nearly didn't hear it then. She has a new song out that sounds nothing at all like this. It made Stereogum's 5 Best Songs of the Week list, which crosses over with my selections all too often. I try to avoid it when possible but the best songs are the best songs so it's hard.

Anyway, I hadn't heard this one because who's going to waste time clicking a link to a song with a bland title like "Forever" by someone with a dull name like Quiet Light? Not me, obviously. But the staffer who picked it, Danielle Chelosky, mentioned the album from earlier this year sounded like "a soft, bright glimpse into the future of music".

Forever certainly doesn't. It sounds more like an eighties soft-rock pastiche to me. I didn't see how that could be the future of anything so I went to YouTube to see what the difference might be. Everything, pretty much, as you can hear for yourself if you listen to both. I only like one of them. I bet you can guess which one.

I also wanted to include Kristen Hersh's new single, Pass Christian, and Armand Hammer's Assembly Lines, but that'd be three out of Stereogum's five for the week and that's just embarrassing, especially since I hadn't heard them before I saw they were on there. It's one thing if I get to them on my own first but you can't just poach everything.

And now, to no-one's surprise more than mine, we're going to the "I literally just found this while I was putting the post together..." section.

On 2 U - Starcrawler

I'd kinda lost track of Starcrawler. They were one of my picks for greatness, about back when I started doing these posts, them and Superorganism. Superorganism pretty much vanished after two albums and some kind of scandal. Starcrawler just kept plugging along but never seemed to get anywhere much. 

Then they seemed to disappear, too. I did a search on them maybe a year ago and didn't find anything new. The last time I posted anything by them seems to have been about four years ago. And now it seems they're back. 

In fact, they've been back all year but they've miraculously managed either not to turn up in any of the music news sites I read every fucking day or I've missed it every fucking time! Modern communications, eh? I just watched three videos for three songs, two of which are very new and one's from earlier this year, and they're all great. I'll save the other two for later but On 2 U is my favorite. (Great live version here, too.) I'm also following them now, which I honestly thought I already was...

 Product of Profit (P.O.P.) - daine

And daine too. Bunch of new tunes, not heard any of 'em. What is going on? Can't even trust the press, now? Subbed her channel as well now, so this will not happen again!

And that's really messed up my finish. I try to keep it to a dozen or so but I guess we're gonna run over. Sorry.

 Winner - Sorry

No, really, Sorry. That's who's up next! I was trying to avoid using anything with no video but that's just too good.

 openinghearts - BOYG1RL

Always was gonna close with that one. It's got that Go Chic Hard Date crunch at the start and that's all I need. Also any excuse to plug Hard Date and I'm gonna take it.

I guess it's time to stop. Shame. I was just starting to get into it. Back to the search for  Christmas Songs I go. This year's Advent Calendar isn't going to program itself. 

Friday, November 13, 2026

Soulframe - Final First Impressions

There are only so many First Impressions posts you can write before you're into just plain Impressions and I feel like I've been playing long enough for that. I don't have any of those nifty little apps that monitor and record how much time I'm spending on each game I play but I think it's fair to say that, since I downloaded Soulframe, most of my gaming time has been taken up by it. 

I generally play games for at least a couple of hours a day. Occasionally I might double that but it would be unusual, so in a full week, which is exactly how long I've had access to the Soulframe Pre-Alpha, I've most likely played games for something like fifteen to twenty hours, in total. I've been doing my dailies in Neverness To Everness and putting in a few sessions of Nivalis Nights, here and there, all of which probably doesn't come to more than six or seven hours, so I'd guess I'm somewhere around ten to twelve hours into Soulframe, at least.

A dozen hours in an MMORPG, is more than enough to build a first impression, I'd say. It's nowhere near enough for a full review, which arguably ought to wait at least until the reviewer has been through the entire leveling process, whatever it is, and even had some experience of the end game, assuming there is one. By which time, if the game isn't in maintenance mode, enough will probably have changed to make the review feel out of date before it even goes to print. No wonder reviewers tend to shy away from the genre.

Twelve hours, however, is surely enough for a Final First Impression. And my Final First Impression is...

Favorable. Shading towards Very Favorable. 

I like the combat. It's tactile, intuitive and robust. It has a solidity that feels satisfying. Granted, I've still only played a ranged class, an archer, so melee and magic might be terrible for all I know, but in my experience archery is one of the hardest combat skills for a designer to pull off. If they can get that right, they shouldn't have too much difficulty with the rest, should they?

 

I like the other side of combat, too: the looting. In any game I play, I really like to see the mobs I kill drop something. Preferably something worth having. That's part of the fun of killing them. 

In Soulframe, mobs drop a lot of loot. They spew out money, crafting mats (Not that I've seen any sign of a crafting system so far..) and weapons among other things. No armor, curiously, although I think there's some kind of fragment system, where you have to collect enough bits to make a whole piece. There's always something to pick up, anyway, and most of it looks like it's going to be useful. When I can figure out what to do with it.

Since we're on the subject of loot, I guess we ought to talk about inventory. I'm nowhere near as obsessed with inventory management as I was when I started this blog but I do like to keep an eye on it.  I can't really venture much of an opinion on how well it's being handled in Soulframe because as of now, I have yet to encounter any storage issues at all.

My character has a backpack that doesn't display. It's well-designed, with plenty of tabs and filters to sort the contents by type and quality and so on. I noticed early on that additional inventory space is one of the things for sale in the Cash Shop and I've just made reference to the large amount of loot that drops off everything you kill, so I was expecting something along the lines of Guild Wars 2, where one of the drivers to get you to spend money is making your bags fill up with crap.

And maybe it will happen but it hasn't happened yet. I pick up literally everything that drops. I also forage all the time. It all goes into that invisible backpack and after a week it's still not full. There's also no weight or size limit. Minnow must be carrying about three dozen assorted weapons now but it's fine; they weigh nothing and take up no space. 

Which is just as well because as yet there's no sign of a bank to store any overspill. In fact, there's little sign of any commercial or social infrastructure at all. 

 

That brings me onto a question I raised briefly last time: is Soulframe really an MMO at all? I could look it up, and I will before I'm done here, but first I'm going to give you my take on it from actual, in-game experience. 

In all the time I've been playing, I've seen no more than half a dozen other players and that was only in two very specific circumstances. In my first session, while I was questing, my Sparrow guide led me to one of those glowing tombstones that turn up all over the map. I had no idea what it was for but I clicked on it anyway and it turned out to be a group-finder. 

In a few seconds I was in a party. I assumed grouping was required for the quest so I went along with it. I was ported into an instance, where a couple of people were running around, killing mobs. No-one said anything, naturally, me included. 

I had no clue what we were supposed to be doing and I never found out. After a couple of minutes I found a ladder going down into a well and since it was there, I used it. Why not? At the bottom was an entrance to the Danak Undercity, which was the first time I knew it existed. My Sparrow told me I needed to go in there for the quest I was on but I figured it would need a group, since that was how I got there in the first place, so I waited. 

No-one else came. After a while I got fed up of waiting and climbed back up the ladder. I was still partied with a couple of people but they were nowhere in sight so I decided to give up on that quest and go back to the open world. I couldn't figure out how to leave the group so in the end I had to log out to get rid of the unwanted company. Later on, I found I hadn't needed to group for the quest at all. Clicking on the party-finder stone had been my mistake. The Sparrow was trying to take me somewhere else entirely.

That was the first time I saw other players. The second and so far last time was when I found the Inn. 

 

The Inn is the only social space of any kind I've located to date. I only found it because there's a quest that takes you there. It's an instance but even so, I was surprised to see a couple of other players running around inside. I'm not sure what they were doing. All I could find to do in there was speak to a faction NPC and hand in some items I had in my pack. 

It was right at the end of a session, though, and I didn't really have a good look around. There might be more services in there. There could even be a bank. I really ought to go back and have another look but that was days ago and I haven't really had any reason to return.

Based on those experiences and the rest of my dozen or so hours in the game, I'd have to guess Soulframe is a lobby MMO. It feels like the open world is entirely a solo affair, although I guess it might also be co-op if you have friends who play. Dungeons, which seem to be quite common  (I clicked on several more stones just to check what they were, then declined to make a group when the pop-up appeared.) have so far been optional, although I wouldn't be at all surprised to find some quests require a party.

And now I'm going to check online to see if that's right... and guess what? It is, or pretty nearly.

Here's how Gemini summarizes it:

"Soulframe is not a true MMORPG; it is an action RPG built around single-player and small-group co-op (typically 3-player parties), with MMO-lite elements very similar to the developers' other game, Warframe"

Well there it is. What puzzles me a little is that I could have sworn, back when I briefly played Warframe, that there were at least some true open-world areas there. I guess I misremembered. 

The thing is... it feels like a proper MMO. Not because of the mechanics but because there's a general chat channel, on by default, in which conversation literally never stops. The entire time I've been playing, chat has been scrolling faster than I can read it. It's a very polite, well-mannered sort of general chat, too, and I'd be happy to have it on, except it's much too distracting. I had to shrink the window so the type was almost too small to read, just so I could concentrate on what I was doing.

On that evidence, I'd say that if you're one of those players who likes the idea of playing games in a social space but who doesn't actually want to interact with other people, except at a time and place of your own choosing, Soulframe would be perfect. Lots of chatter to make it feel sociable but no-one sniping your mobs or sending you invites to do things you don't want to do.

 

For me, that can go on the Good Things About Soulframe list, along with Combat, Inventory Management, UI, Graphics, Environment and Sound. The last two need a bit of clarifying, though. The first because I've been slightly misleading in some of the things I've said about it and the second because I haven't mentioned it at all until now.

On the Environment, as Tyler Edwards pointed out in a comment, the reason the entire world looks so miserable is because it's been corrupted. A big part of the gameplay involves you, the player, restoring the land to its former charm. You have to destroy Syphons, which is a whole feature I have yet to experience, so I'll leave it at that for now. Just be advised, the world won't always look so awful.

Another environmental feature I haven't mentioned yet are the World Trees. The map is covered with Fog of War but you can't clear it just by exploring. You have to find the big trees with something that looks like a pitchfork rammed through the trunk and then you have to pull the pitchfork out. That clears a large area of the map, which is great. What's not so great is that there's no way to tell where the trees are, other than by bumping into one by chance. I think some kind of indicator to give a hint at least where to start looking would be helpful.

As for the sound, it's very good, by which I mean it's actually useful. There's some voice acting, which I wouldn't put any higher than competent and professional but the ambient sound is very good. There's bugger all wildlife thanks to the corruption, so there's no cheerful hum of birdsong and insect calls, but the infernal machinery makes appropriately sinister noises and you can hear people at work in the camps.

The really effective use of sound, though, is the yells of your enemies. Every last humanoid mob speaks or more often shouts as soon as they gain aggro on you, which is extremely helpful of them. Thanks to the rain and fog and the smart but annoying tendency of the enemy to use cover effectively, I often can't see where the arrows or the fireballs are coming from. But I can hear! Minnow echo-locates like a bat half the time. It's very organic.

 

You can, as it happens, make the enemy light up so you can see them more easily. It's a talent you put points into. I only figured out how to use it today. Which brings up the main thing I don't particularly like about the game: the over-complicated, often awkward mechanics.

I suspect much of this may come from the game having been designed first for controllers rather than keyboard or mouse, but some of the combinations required to do things feel far from natural. There's too much pressing and holding two keys and I really don't think the scroll wheel on the mouse ought to come into things at all.

I've had a quest to equip, charge and use a rune for about five days now and I still haven't been able to do it. At first I thought I'd just play and it would become obvious but that never happened so I googled it and read the very lengthy explanation Gemini gave me. 

Maybe it's just me, but I feel that if an AI needs five paragraphs to summarize the mechanics of a simple thing like charging and casting a rune, your design might need a rethink. Still, at least now I knew what I had to do... So I did it and it still didn't work! I've equipped my rune and charged it now but can I figure out how to fire it? Can I hell! I even watched a YouTube video and it still didn't make it clear.  

This isn't all that unusual in my experience so far. I had to redo the quest to get the wolf pup pet three times because twice the key for the cage didn't drop. I didn't do anything wronmg and it isn't exactly a bug. It's just too finnicky to be 100% reliable. It's worth it, though. The pup is very cute and apparently one day Minnow will be able to ride her as a mount. Which, since there seems to be no instant travel at all, will be nice.

These kinds of things are quite common, it seems. Remember all that buzz in General Chat I was talking about earlier? At least half of it must be people trying to find out how to do something the game isn't letting them do. Or more likely isn't making it clear how to do. It's in this way that Soulframe really does feel like a Pre-Alpha.

 

Another thing I'm not fond of is the extent to which the developers seem to be excited by their own lore and jargon. I've been talking about "questing" but that's not a word the game uses. It doesn't say"missions", either, which would be equally acceptable. Soulframe likes to call those things it wants you to do "Votives" or "Fables". 

Fables are Main Story Quests. Votives are side quests. I had to look that up. It was not clear to me at all just from playing the game. I know it's boring , using the same language as everyone else, but conventions exist for a reason, guys! 

If you want to see just how off-putting the shop-talk can be, try reading the recent Update notes. I'm broadly in favor of in-character patch notes, especially when it's done for laughs, but this is just too much flavor for something that's primarily meant to be informative, particularly for a new player. I know that, after a while, meaning will seep into all those currently incomprehensible words and I'll stop noticing how uncomfortably self-conscious it all sounds but this is a First Impressions piece and I'm not quite there yet. 

I am, however, at the end of both the post and my initiation into the game. No more First Impressions from now on. Just play reports and opinions. Although I suspect it will be hard to tell the difference. 

My tl:dr for an overall first impression of the game? Some work still to be done but, all things considered, very promising. 

Very promising indeed! 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Every Night, When The Stars Come Out

I never really reviewed the first season of Edgerunners, even though I wrote about it several times and stuck the label on half a dozen posts. I wrote more about the soundtrack than I did about the show itself and the only reason I watched it at all was because Rosa Walton of Let's Eat Grandma did a song specifically for the show. 

That song turned out to be the iconic I Really Want To Stay At Your House, which soundtracks the equally iconic ending of the final episode. You know you're not exploiting the overused "iconic" accolade, when you only have to think of the song and it all comes back. Well, not if you have a memory like mine, anyway. Not to mention the official video for the song on Netflix' YouTube channel has ninety-five million views...

The soundtrack to Season 2 isn't quite up to the standard of the first but it's pretty good all the same. I was very surprised and not a little delighted to see Petit Meller put in an appearance with two songs, including the closing theme. Using the Cure's 10.15 Saturday Night for the opening was a counterintuitive masterstroke. Fifty year old minimalism meets future maximalism and it's perfect.

Competing with all of that iconicism from series one was always going to be tough, though. At the time, I never thought they'd even try. At the end of the first season I wrote 

"Without getting too spoilery, the series pretty much ran as a one-and-done, the ending leaving little room for a second season, the final episode being one of the more conclusive and downbeat resolutions I've seen for a while." 

Yeah. True, that. And so there was a second season anyway. It just didn't have anyone from the first season in it. What them all being...

Hang on a moment. It's pretty much spoilers all the way down from here. I guess we'd better have a 

 S P O I L E R    W A R N I N G !

...dead and all.

So, Season 2 has the same setting and some of the same themes but none of the same characters. It was also mostly made by the same people. Is it as good?

No, of course it's not. That would be too much to hope for. 

Sidebar - I had a sarcastic paragraph here that I had to remove, where I was saying it's a bad idea to go iconic with your first season of anything because where are you going to go from there? But then I realized there are probably shows that managed to start out iconic and then top it second time out, so if I was going to say otherwise, I'd need to go do a whole lot of research to stand it up and I really didn't want to do that, so I just cut the whole thing. See that? That's the magic happening right there...

How do you write a second season of a show when not a single significant character from the first is left alive? Oh, wait... Lucy... (And Falco, according to Gemini, who I have doing my fact-checking for me, which is a bit like having Freewheeling Franklin monitoring your medication, but I can't off the top of my head remember who Falco was, so I'm not going to worry too much about forgetting him...)

Apparently you do it by setting the sequel in the future, albeit only by a couple of years and by having a brand new set of leads, not one of whom has any connection to the last lot. And it might work, too, given the star of the entire IP is arguably Night City itself. 

Except you don't really get to see a lot of Night City in Season 2. I mean it's there but it's hardly a focus, more a backdrop. In the foreground there's just a bunch of people, none of whom seems to have all that much to do with any of the others to begin with but by the end of the ten episodes... they still don't.

Oh, they do if you go by the plot. They all get to meet and do things with each other or to each other and all their individual stories intertwine except they don't much have individual stories. They have vaguely sketched-in backstories but what they don't have is much of a sense of belonging together. They meet, they do stuff, they leave. That's it. The first Season had a Crew. The second has some people who happen to be going in the same direction for a while. It's hardly enough.

I think the best way to describe the show might be to record my feelings on each of the main characters. I can at least remember them, which is a tick in the positives column, although it has only been barely twelve hours since I watched the closing credits. I'll take them in the order they come to me, which ought to say something about how memorable I found them.

  

Roman - I liked Roman. That seems to be a minority position, based on some of the reviews and Reddit threads I skimmed after the final episode ended. A lot of the audience for this kind of show really doesn't like children, that's the vibe I'm getting. 

Roman is a twelve year-old boy with an antique video camera and an obsessive desire to film everything that happens. Why he has it and why he became so driven to make home movies was either not explained or I missed it, although I do remember it was money that drove him to attempt to get footage of a crew of mercenaries called Maelstrom, which is what leads to his involvement with the whole escalating clusterfuck to begin with. 

Roman doesn't really have much of a personality but he has more excuse for that than most of the cast, not having had as long to develop one. He's a weirdly innocent child, given the circumstances of his life, although even as I type that, I realize we know absolutely nothing of those circumstances. He comes across as bashful, modest, certain only of his great ability with the camera and apparently on loan from the 1950s. He also seems to have some kind of superpower (Metaphorically, I should make it clear.) that means he could probably walk through a collapsing building without even getting dust on his lens. Then again, everyone else seems to be able to get up and walk away from explosions or collisions that would crush a bus, so maybe invulnerability is a Night City thing.

If Roman has any traits on his character sheet other than Blank Slate they'll probably be Everyman and Moral Compass. He's an okay stand-in for the viewer but he's really not qualified to offer a moral center, even if he's probably the only member of the cast who doesn't kill anyone for the entire ten episodes. Still, he sure as hell hangs around with the ones who do and he does very little to stop any of it. I like him but he's hardly there a lot of the time. He's a cipher. The only time he shows any real emotional involvement is when someone tries to leave him, which suggests abandonment issues. Or he's just annoying, which is another popular viewpoint.

 

D - D stands for David. David is called David because the central character in Season One was called David. Not that he's related to him or even knew him. The writers thought it would be a way to link the two stories. They were wrong. It's just a bit confusing. The actual link is that both Davids were nominally included in some kind of corporate deviance concerning individuals with a greater than normal resistance to cyber-psychosis. Their names are in the same files and that's it.  

D appears out of nowhere to save Roman from the Maelstrom crew, who have him hog-tied and are about cut him open to give him cybber implants he doesn't want. It's a disturbing scene, possibly the most unsettling in the whole run. D comes in, acting like a superhero. He pretty much looks like one, too. At this point he's cool and he seems admirable. 

It's all downhill from there as he reveals himself to be a borderline alcoholic, self-medicating for his extreme PTSD. It gets much worse as he succumbs to depression and mania and finally something that looks a lot like psychosis. He does have a tragic backstory but I found it pretty hard to sympathize with him as he moved from specific revenge against the individuals he believed had slaughtered his tribe to pretty much killing anyone who looked at him funny, then sitting around watching while a whole load of D-Wannabes played riot games. The scene where one of his acolytes casually shoots a cowering girl in the head was a highlight.

By the time we get to the last episode, where there's an attempt to recapture the magic of the first season's final moments, it's so obvious none of it has been earned it's embarrassing. We'd need to like D by then for that to come off. I sure didn't. Does anyone like him? Even Roman calls him an idiot.

 

Weak - Weak is apparently what David from Season One would have become if things had gone differently; if he'd lived out his life as an Edgerunner. He'd have gone full cyber-psychotic, murdered a bunch of people for no reason, then had all his cyberware stripped out for his, and everyone else's, safety, leaving him a powerless husk, unable to back up the threats he'd carry on making.

Weak (Real name Weak Kingsley, once known as King. Oh, the symbolism...) is quite an endearing character in his way. He's certainly loyal. And stubborn. And deluded if he thinks he can pull off any of the things he says he can. Mostly he gets beaten up - a lot - and all his attempts to do just about anything fail. Still, he's giving it his best shot and he's generally trying to do something that could just about be seen as the right thing, if you squinted really hard... 

Weak also believes (Wrongly, as it turns out.) that he's the real father of

Talia - She's made to be everyone's favorite. A feisty teenage girl with a smart mouth and a terminal illness. How could she not be? Plus she has a horrible father and an overprotective mother and she's just Trying To Live Her Own Life, Her Way. Talk about stacking the pack...

So, yes, I liked Talia. It'd be bloody-minded not to. She doesn't actually kill people for one thing, well, not until right at the end, when she does make up for it but then there are mitigating factors. She's also genuinely nice to poor old Roman when she could quite justifiably tell him to get lost. Then again, she's very short with him at other times. Still, teenage mood swings... And she must be on a lot of drugs...

 

Kyoko - Kyoko is... hmm. What is Kyoko? About three feet tall for a start. For several episodes I thought I was watching another child, probably someone younger than Roman. I also thought I was looking at a boy. 

Kyoko turns out to be an adult woman. Everyone in the cast immediately accepts this as if it's obvious. They are clearly seeing something I'm not. She's a Mad Scientist of the old school. She looks and acts like she's in a 1970s Saturday morning cartoon, except for all the murdering. She was involved in a project that somehow condensed a whole lot of human consciousnesses into an AI. She did that for the same Corp that was the big villain in Season 1, Arasaka. Her project cost them a fortune, didn't show enough results and got shut down. Is she bitter? What do you think?

Her AI, which was on a chip, somehow got lost. I expect that got explained but I don't remember any of it. The chip somehow ends up in D's slot and Kyoko wants it back. She tries to catfish Roman for it, she sucks up to Talia's Bad Father, who's an Exec in another Corp. She promises him all the same things she promised Arasaka and he goes for it because he really is an idiot. Just because he's also a prick doesn't make him smart.

Kyoko starts out as an unmitigated villain but there seems to be some sort of half-assed attempt to engage our sympathies for her in the last couple of episodes. It's like wrapping a feather boa round a rattlesnake and asking people to cuddle it. I was not fooled. She's a fun character all the same. Just not in any way lovable. Or believable. 

 

Capricorn - Aka Capri. Capri is an AI. Or something like that. A digital consciousness? She's a hoot, anyway. I bet everyone loves Capri. She's two-dimensional, as in she's a flat drawing in a medium that's all flat drawings and yet somehow she manages to look flatter than everything else. She's red but she's also green, when she gets split. She's in the chip and she's in whoever the chip's in, which is mostly D until it's also Talia. They each get some Capri. Then Talia gets it all and there's no more Talia, only Capri, until D gets the chip back and there's no more D or Capri because they went to space and now look! Talia's back.The few bits that are left of her after the EMP and the airstrike, anyway. Did you miss her? Yes, we missed her. 

Capri is a lot of fun, visually and verbally. She probably kills more people than everyone else put together but she's an AI so it doesn't count. Talia's Last Dying Wish is for Capri to kill Bad Dad in the most gruesome way possible. She does her best but in the end a building falls on him.

Okay, I think that's all the ones I think of as Main Cast. Let me see if I missed anyone... 

Nope, that's the lot, although where you draw the line between Main Cast and Supporting Cast is a judgment call. Gemini only gives Roman, D, Weak and Talia the honor. No Capri. No loyalty among AIs, apparently.

There are quite a few significant supporting characters, including Avida and Kiril (Talia's mom and dad, both dead now, so Talia's an orphan, I guess.), Omi (D's old friend from the tribal days. I liked her. She wasn't in it enough.), and Yupi (Harley Quinn to D's Joker. She was good value. The writers gave her more subtext than pretty much anyone. She could have made for an interesting spin-off if she hadn't gotten shot.) but my rule is that if I had to look up their names, they can't be Main Cast and I had to look up all of those.

 

That makes for a fairly chaotic overview which is fair because it's a fairly chaotic series. I think the writers might have been aiming for that Robert Altman gestalt, where you just keep introducing character after character and eventually some kind of shape to the story just coalesces around them. And it kinda does do that... it's just not a very good story.

Entertaining, though. I'll happily give it entertaining. I enjoyed every episode. The last couple are a real thrill-ride, even if I found it close to impossible to take any of it remotely seriously. Kyoko on her tricycle, racing to stop the bombs with the EMP in her backpack is like Elliot and his pals trying to save ET on their pushbikes, only played for laughs.

Apart from having absolutely none of the gravitas or emotional heft of the first season, Season 2 of Edgerunners is also more cartoony and feels much lighter, even with all the endless murdering and exploding heads. In part that's because most of the cast survive and there's something that's not a million miles from a happy ending. The final scenes of Season 1 are authentically harrowing. I can't say I'm sorry we didn't get a rerun.

I'll just throw in a word of praise for the voice acting, which is uniformly excellent. Every major character is a joy to listen to. The standard of voice acting is so high these days, though, it's all too easy to take excellence for granted. Same for the animation, really. We just expect it to be this good now. And it is.

Whether we needed a Season 2 at all is another question but since we got one, I'll take it. It was a good watch while it was on but I don't imagine I'll go back to it again. It just made me want to rewatch the first one. 

There's no word on a Season 3. Clearly, if they're going to use this episodic "Tales of Night City" approach, they can keep going as long as the interest is there. I suspect they won't but I won't be annoyed if they do. 

Either way is good with me. 

Wider Two Column Modification courtesy of The Blogger Guide